Which is better lme or dme

Being in powder form also allows for much easier weighing compared to LME when not using an entire package. What this means is as soon as the DME is exposed to air it begins taking in moisture which in turn causes the powder to clump and become a hassle to work with.

You may have experienced this when trying to dump DME directly from the package into a boil. This can even happen by simply being in a humid environment. All things considered, each form of malt extract has its pros and cons. Based on your brewing process and goals, you may find that one is better suited for your situation than the other. Or it may vary from one recipe to the next. A great way to find out which extracts you prefer is to test them each out in a miniature batch of beer.

Add a few ounces of extract to a quart of water and boil for minutes. Wanting to make sure the variable in question was at the forefront, I designed recipes that would rely entirely on either LME or DME, which required different amounts in order to achieve the same expected OG. The week before my planned brew day, I ordered Pilsner extracts of either type from MoreBeer, crossing my fingers that they would be of similar freshness.

When the package arrived two days later, I was pleased to discover the dates on each differed by just a few days. When brew day arrived, I collected two identical volumes of filtered water, which I left unadulterated.

While the water was warming up, I weighed out the hop additions for both batches. Refractometer readings showed my calculations were pretty spot on, as both batches achieved the same OG. Identical volumes of wort from each batch were then transferred to sanitized Brew Buckets. Click pic for Ss Brewtech Brew Bucket review.

I observed airlock activity in both beers just 6 hours later and fermentation proceeded similarly for each. With signs of activity all but absent 8 days later, I took hydrometer measurements indicating the LME beer finished slightly higher than the DME beer. The filled kegs were placed in my keezer and burst carbonated overnight before I reduced the gas to serving pressure. After a week of conditioning, they were equally carbonated and ready to serve to tasters.

A total of 32 people of varying levels of experience participated in this xBmt. Each participant was served 2 samples of the beer made with liquid malt extract and 1 sample of the beer made with dry malt extract in different colored opaque cups then asked to identify the unique sample. The 16 participants who made the accurate selection on the triangle test were instructed to complete a brief preference survey comparing only the beers that were different. A total of 7 tasters reported preferring the LME beer, another 7 said they liked the DME beer more, 2 had no preference despite noticing a difference, and 2 reported perceiving no difference.

While recent data suggests more and more folks are jumping directly into all-grain brewing, due in part to the rise in popularity of methods like Brew In A Bag, using malt extracts remains an easy way to see what this gig is all about. However, the fact tasters in this xBmt were capable of reliably telling apart beers made with either LME or DME suggests each type of extract produces unique characteristics.

Considering the fairly split preference ratings, it might be easy to assume that despite the beers being perceptibly different, both were equally as good. As someone who only uses malt extract for xBmts specifically focused on malt extract, my experience with these beers did little to change my opinion on the ingredient.

That said, my previously held conviction, which was beaten into me during my first few years of brewing, that LME is of higher quality than DME has certainly changed.

If you have any thoughts about this xBmt, please do not hesitate to share in the comments section below! DVoors and DrMindbender like this. I used to buy the 50 lb box and would finish it in about 3 - 4 months. I bagged it in 3 and 4 lb increments in zip lock bags. I did not have a problem with it clumping and it stayed fairly fresh but I did store all of the bags in an air tight container.

After about 3 boxes I decided I would rather pay the extra money then break it up myself. DME is not fun to weigh out and bag. It sticks everywhere and gets in the air very easily.

If I tried to dump it in the bag fast it kind of looked like when Lebron James throws that powder up in the air before games. My one piece of advice is to use the big zip locks.

Staples sells folders that are made out of cheap flexable plastic material. I would put one of those in the ziplock to cover up where it seals. That way when I scoop the DME into the bag it does not stick to the sides and to the ziplock portion of the bag.

Once it was at the weight I wanted I would pull out the folder and seal it up with as little air in there as possible. Yeah, I know. It's just an extra faff that I'd rather do without. Joined Jun 2, Messages Reaction score Location wolverhampton.

I wonder if anyone can help with this query please. I am thinking of digging out my 30 year old Electrim bin later this year and doing an AG brew but see that the products have changed massively since I last used it. I sometimes used to use just DME plus sugar and crystal malt etc.

I will pay whatever I need to in order to produce a decent brew but do wonder why LME seems so much cheaper and if it has disadvantages. I note that some on here say it is more likely to create the dreaded twang. Cheshire Cat Landlord. I made a few 10L brews with the MJ 1. But a few years back I used to use Coopers 1.

You must log in or register to reply here. Latest posts. General Beer Brewing Discussion. Change one letter. The Snug. General Beer Discussion. Common word pairs. Latest: Soupforlunch 21 minutes ago. Word association Latest: Soupforlunch 22 minutes ago.